4'-Substituted bicyclic pyridones were prepared and evaluated as non-steroidal inhibitors of type 1 and 2 steroid 5alpha-reductase (SR). A range of 4'-substituents were incorporated into the bicyclic scaffold to investigate SAR within and across different classes of non-steroidal inhibitors of SR. Bicyclic pyridones containing a 4'-benzoyl or long carbon chain tether showed more potent inhibition against type 1 SR than inhibitors with N-substituted acetamide groups in the 4'-position. SAR derived from 4'-substituted bicyclic pyridones reported here do not correlate with SAR derived from known potent 4'-substituted biaryl acid SR inhibitors. A 4'-benzoyl group is favoured by the active site in both isozymes.